Nvidia Was One Deep

What a $4 trillion company forgot to plan for

"If you do something for 34 years, you can figure it out."

Jensen Huang said this ten months before he was out of the company he founded, at the center of an international scandal.

Nvidia had no one ready.

In that same talk, in Las Vegas in January, he called Nvidia the captain of the industry, with supply chain and collaboration partners all over the world counting on it to do its part. "So there is a great responsibility that comes with our company," he said.

On November 12, during the aftermath of a spicy midterm election season, he resigned, days after admitting to an extramarital affair with an alleged Chinese spy.

Huang knew the weight of the responsibility that he bore. As the leader of the most influential tech giant in the world, he was not ignorant of the responsibilities of that level of leadership. And yet, he still risked it all.

My question is not why. Unrelated to Alice Huang, I'm sure there are more than enough reasons we could imagine that could put him in a sticky situation. My heart goes out to his family, and to everyone affected by the fallout.

So my question isn't "Why would someone do something like that?" 

My question is, how did Nvidia allow this to happen?

The answer is soberingly simple: the company was One Deep.

The company was One Deep

I’m not a football fan (and I live in Colorado. This is already an unpopular statement for me to make as an American, let alone a Coloradan in Broncos territory.) But it’s true. No matter how much I’ve tried, which isn’t much, I just can’t get into the sport. 

But recently, when searching for a name for our 2027 workshop series for CEOs, I ran across the term “One Deep” and learned that this concept is used all over the sports and military worlds.

Essentially, every position on a team has a depth chart: the starter’s name on top, and below it, the people ready to run onto the field if the starter goes down. Two deep means that when the quarterback gets hurt in the second quarter, someone is already warming up on the sideline. One deep means the coach turns around, looks down the bench, and sees no one.

In a company, it looks the same. One person holds the decisions, the relationships, or the know-how, and if they go down, there’s nobody on the sideline ready to go in.

Which brings us back to Nvidia.

"Jensen is a very unique CEO. There is no known succession plan," Daniel Newman, CEO of the Futurum Group, told Bloomberg last week.

Here’s the trap: the better the CEO, the easier it is to never build a bench. Nobody worries about the backup when the starter never misses a game.

I see it at every size. I once worked with a founder who had never taken a vacation without closing her office. Not once. If she wasn’t there, the business wasn’t open. She was that good, and everyone around her, including her, had quietly built the company around it.

But being that good isn’t an excuse. Not for a founder with a 20-person team, and certainly not for a company worth trillions.

Finding the right guy, or girl, to replace the charismatic, talented CEO isn’t easy. Think for a moment about the shoes that the next leader has to fill.

Exactly.

Not easy, but also not impossible. And at Nvidia’s size, it isn’t optional.

Two bombs at once

When I read the reports on this incident last week, my jaw nearly fell onto the floor. I voice noted my friend and colleague Amanda Heller, since she and I host in-person workshops (aptly named One Deep) where we humanely take apart cases like this one with the leaders in the room.

"Hey," I spoke into the mic on the phone amid the background noise of a bustling café. "Check out what's happening with Nvidia right now."

2 minutes later my phone dinged with a two word reply from her: "Holy sh*t."

Then another text: "I hate saying I told you so. But…. Nvidia…. I told you so."

She hadn't personally told the board of Nvidia that this would happen. But we routinely tell our clients that this is the stuff we are working with them to avoid. Sometimes it’s hard for them to imagine what could go so wrong, when everything is going so right at the moment. 

What makes this situation so rare is that Nvidia got hit from the inside and the outside at the same time.

The inside is my side of the work: how leaders communicate, how decisions get made, and who they get made by. My framework, The Holographic Model of Leadership™, rests on one idea. Whatever is unresolved in a leader gets amplified, then distributed throughout the organization, for better or worse. At Nvidia, one man held dozens of direct reports and decades of key relationships. When the leader is the structure, whatever happens to him happens to the company. But it goes much deeper. There were unresolved issues inside the leader himself. And these issues were amplified, then distributed. That broadly defines how I help protect the internal affairs of an organization and its leadership.

But externally, there’s a whole other side of risk, which is what my colleague specializes in. Customers, suppliers, reputation, and in this case, geopolitics and even alleged espionage. Amanda spent her career as an Air Force officer dealing with highly sensitive material, and she and Naledi Group use frameworks like the 4 Dependencies to find those exposures before they find you.

Rarely do both bombs go off at once.

Lucky for Nvidia, it’s a giant among giants, and it will most likely survive this. I hope the country does, too.

Just typing that made me a little sick to my stomach.

But it’s true.

And it shows the kind of fallout most boards never see coming until it’s already on the front page.

In a matter of days, Nvidia’s board had to face it all at once: there was no succession plan (I still struggle to believe this), questions of national security were landing squarely on their table, and they needed to cover every base immediately. By Friday, the company had an interim CEO who was also still its CFO, the first board chair in its history, and no search firm hired yet to find its next leader.

That’s what scrambling looks like at $4 trillion.

And the hardest piece to replace won’t show up on any org chart. As Steven Dickens of HyperFrame Research pointed out, Huang’s decades-long relationships with industry leaders would be very hard for anyone to replace.

Which leaves the questions every board should be asking right now. Who knew about the affair? Who knew about other parts of this story and did nothing? And who knew Nvidia was one deep, and either didn’t know what to do about it, or knew and didn’t act?

This story may only last another week or two in the news cycle. For the board, for Huang’s family, and for Huang himself, it’s far from over.

If you're in the game long enough

You don’t need to be a tech giant to end up here. You just need to be in the game long enough. A diagnosis, a divorce, a lawsuit. A post that goes viral for all the wrong reasons.

Your turn will come. The only question is whether anyone is standing on the sideline when it does.

Huang co-founded Nvidia and ran it for 33 years. In January, asked how long he’d stay, he said: “For as long as I deserve it.” According to Fortune, he owned less than 4% of the company, with no special voting shares to protect his seat. Officially, he resigned. CNBC reported the board had made that decision the night before.

The timing wasn’t his to choose.

Most founders assume theirs will be.

So I’ll ask you: if you didn’t walk into your company tomorrow, who would make the first three calls?

Previous
Previous

The Holographic Model of Leadership™: Why Your Company Carries Your Fingerprints

Next
Next

Renewable Microgrid Design